Nesiocypraea lisetae, maricola, and look-alikes

Nesiocypraea lisetae is a widespread, yet rare, deep-water species whose conchological features are easily overlooked (beause of its small size), but obvious enough when looked at under magnification. One would think that a shell is carefully examined when it comes to deciding whether it could possibly be a rarity like lisetae, but the opposite seems to be the case. On every shell-auction on the web, on lists of shell dealers (even some whose names I actually have heared before) and of course on shell-shows, a lot of look-alikes are offered as lisetae, but a quick glance tells you they are not. In the following I will show you where to look.

But first, let us admire the beauty and variability of Nesiocypraea lisetae. The species was originally described by Kilburn 1975, from Natal, South Africa. One year later, Cate described Nesiocypraea maricola from the Philippines. Both names were given to what is now considered subspecies of the same species. The name maricola is stands for shells from the Pacific. These tend to have more distinctly pointed tips than their South African relatives. The MNHN Paris has dredged small specimens from New Caledonia, Vanuatu, Fiji and the Austral Islands in eastern Polynesia. These shells are even more rostrate than their western Pacific allies. Nesiocypraea lisetae is mostly found ex pisce in South Africa, but shells have been dredged as well, usually at depths ranging from 70 to 150 m. In the Philippines, it was found by dredging and in tangle nets, off 100 to 200 m. The Japanese shells are found by dredging at 200 m, in New Caledonia and the Austral Islands, shells were found from 100 to 1000 m depth. This makes N. lisetae one of the deepest living species in the Cypraeidae.

Generally, lisetae is inflated, with sharply pointed extremities and a narrow aperture, closely resembling the species of Pustularia. The dorsum is usually pink to pale cream, ornamented with a slightly darker blotch. There are discrete spots mostly along the margins.  The aperture is curved behind, and the posterior tip on columellar (left) side is as long or even longer than the labral one. The teeth are short, and connected with a callus-bridge on both sides, especially labrally. This feature is uniquely found in lisetae and distinguishes it easily from any species of Pustularia.

distribution of Nesiocypraea lisetae
The distribution of Nesiocypraea lisetae (red dots mark ascertained sites where the species has been collected)

Nesiocypraea lisetae from South Africa
Nesiocypraea lisetae, 14 mm, from Natal, South Africa. the extremities are rounded posteriorly.

Nesiocypraea lisetae from South Africa
Nesiocypraea lisetae, 15 mm, Natal, South Africa

Nesiocypraea lisetae from Mozambique
Nesiocypraea lisetae, 16 mm, Mozambique. Locality unconfirmed

Nesiocypraea lisetae from Japan
Nesiocypraea lisetae, 15 mm, Japan


Nesiocypraea lisetae maricola from Philippines
Nesiocypraea lisetae maricola, 12 mm, from the Philippines

Nesiocypraea lisetae var. maricola
Nesiocypraea lisetae maricola, 13 mm, from the Philippines

Nesiocypraea lisetae var. maricola from the Austral Is.
Nesiocypraea lisetae maricola, 10 mm, from Rurutu (Austral Is.)

Nesiocypraea lisetae showing characteristic teeth
In this specimen of Nesiocypraea lisetae maricola from the Philippines the teeth have been stained with a pencil. Note that there is a distinct ridge connecting them. It is especially obvious in the posterior part of the columellar side. If you compare this region with the look-alikes (see below) you will see the difference instantly.

Lisetae look-alikes

lisetae look-alike
The subadult of Pustularia bistrinotata are most commonly confused with lisetae.
Note that the teeth are not connected by a callus-ridge.

cicercula looks like lisetae (at least a bit)
The subadult of Pustularia cicercula can be superficially similar to lisetae.
Note that the teeth are not connected by a callus-ridge, they are not even extending at all.

cicercula
This subadult of Pustularia cicercula is quite similar in shape to lisetae.
Note that again the teeth are not connected by a callus-ridge, and the aperture is rather straight.

margarita
This subadult of Pustularia margarita is also similar in shape to lisetae.
Note that again the teeth are not connected by a callus-ridge - very obvious posteriorly on columellar side - and the aperture is rather straight.

margarita
This exceptional specimen of P. margarita has a curved aperture and rather short extremities.
However, once again the teeth are obviously those of a Pustularia.

globulus
For the sake of completeness, a juvenile Pustularia globulus which looks a bit weird,
so people that never saw a real lisetae might get fooled by such a thing as well.

In any case:
1) there will be owners and sellers of the look-alikes that will try to argue they got the "real thing" for cheap, and others that will bombard me with photos of ... look alikes.
2) still a lot of people will go for that bargain specimen on eBay...
3) there will be more of those shells than true lisetae in the years to come.

A dealer in faked diamond rings can only survive if there are enough people who want to believe that the ring is real. Belief has no place in the world of science, so it is entirely the individual's choice which way the wind blows.

first uploaded 2009, updated 2021